I’ve been a fan of ebooks for more than five years now, ever since I bought a CD-ROM containing 1,000 works of classical literature for reading on my laptop. Wanting a more portable electronic reading experience, I graduated to a PDA a couple years later, and finally, bought Amazon’s Kindle — a dedicated ebook reader — at the beginning of July. Now that I’ve been using Kindle for a couple months, I finally feel ready to give you my review of the product. Since this is probably going to be a long one, I’ve decided to break the review up into two parts: the Pros and Cons. I’ll start with the Cons here.
In all honesty, my first impression of the Kindle was not a good one. It was hard to get started with it because the instruction manual is very short and lacks detailed explanations of how to do things. All the manual does is list the functions of the different buttons, but it doesn’t tell you how to manage content, switch between different titles, enter the owner’s name and info, set a screensaver, check the time, etc. This wouldn’t have been so bad in and of itself if the user interface on the device was intuitive, but it’s not. As a result, it was very difficult (and frustrating) trying to figure out how to get started.
Now that I’ve been using the Kindle for a while, all the basic functions are second nature, but at the beginning this was definitely not the case. I would have preferred a better instruction manual for sure. As it was, I was forced to check several online sources to help figure things out.
Another thing I didn’t particularly like about the Kindle was the layout of the page turn buttons. These buttons take up both sides of the device, making it difficult to pick up the Kindle without accidentally turning the pages.

Moreover, I like to read while lying down in bed or on the sofa. Not propped up with pillows or anything; just fully supine. It took me FOREVER to try to find a comfortable way of holding the Kindle so I could read it while lying down. At first, I couldn’t do it and had to sit up to read, but now I’ve finally figured it out and can read comfortably in any position.
A third problem I had with the Kindle was with document conversion. Actually, I shouldn’t use the past tense there, as these problems are ongoing. Amazon offers a free conversion service that turns selected file types (.html, .pdf, etc.) into .azw files that are readable by Kindle. I’d say that this conversion process only works on about 80% of the documents I’ve sent in, which is not that great a rate considering this stuff is supposed to be fully supported.
When conversion works, it’s very quick and easy, but it’s extremely frustrating to get emails saying, “There was a problem with your documents…” No, the problem isn’t with my documents, it’s with the conversion process!
Because of this, I have to keep my PDA around to read any ebooks that can’t be converted to Kindle files, which is a pain in the ass.
And my final problem with Kindle has to do with the cheap cover provided by Amazon. This thing is made of faux leather and does NOT hold the Kindle in place securely. At first, I had to take the Kindle out of the cover to read it, which I thought partially defeated the purpose of a protective cover. Yeah, it’s great to have the device covered when it’s sitting on my shelf, but I need it covered when I’m reading it too in case it accidentally slips out of my hand or something (like when I nod off while reading).

Thanks to other Kindle owners’ tips, however, I was able to rig the case and device with Velcro strips. This has done the trick very nicely and now my Kindle is completely secure in its cover. But still — you’d think that a device that costs $350+ would come with a better cover….
As you can see, there are relatively few Cons to the Amazon Kindle. These problems are minor, and with the exception of document conversion, can easily be overcome after the user gets accustomed to the device. Overall, while these annoyances are certainly troublesome, they’re not significant enough to prevent me from recommending the Kindle as a good buy.