I mentioned a little while back that I purchased a Reebok Women’s NFL Replica jersey from ESPNshops.com. I went with an Alex Smith jersey in size XL, and was surprised at how different it was compared to the Tom Brady replica I have. As a result, I’ve decided to write a complete review highlighting the differences here.
First of all, I bought the Brady jersey a couple years ago when Reebok first started the women’s replica line. At that time, the jerseys were NOT see-thru mesh like the men’s jerseys are. They were made from a double layer of mesh or something so you couldn’t really see through it. I actually liked that style at the time because it meant that I didn’t have to wear another shirt underneath the jersey.

With the mesh jersey, I’m forced to wear at least two shirts now (for obvious reasons). I’m a bit torn as to which style I prefer. On the one hand, I hate layering up when I don’t have to. For example, even though it’s October, we’re still having 70-80 degree weather here in Chicago, making it pretty uncomfortable to sit through football games with two shirts on. But on the other hand, the mesh style looks far more authentic than the solid material. So I guess it comes down to a matter of comfort/convenience versus looks.

I think all of the Reebok women’s replicas are mesh now, so just be aware of that if you haven’t bought a new one in a while. This fact was noted in the product description and was apparent in the photos; I just wasn’t paying close enough attention, I guess.
Another thing that’s different is the collar. My Brady jersey has a very thick V-neck collar that measures an inch across. This collar is very noticeable because it’s so different from the men’s jersey styles. Take a look at this photo for reference.

The newer Smith jersey, on the other hand, has the usual thin V-neck collar that you see on the real jerseys — along with the “NFL Equipment” shield that’s not present on the Brady version. This one measures just .4 inches thick, making it much, much better than the old style. Take a look.

Yet another difference is that the newer Smith jersey comes with a tag where you can write your name (I don’t do this, of course, but it looks more like the men’s jerseys this way). The Brady jersey just has a generic Reebok tag. Here are more comparison photos.


And finally, the Brady jersey tapers in at the waist to fit the female form a bit better. While the description for the Smith jersey says that it does the same, the taper isn’t noticeable at all. This could be due to the fact that I bought an XL this time around, but I’m not sure about that. I don’t care for the tapered fit on a football jersey anyway, so this wasn’t a big deal for me. I just thought you should know about this before you buy.
Overall, I think my Smith jersey is waaay better than the Brady jersey I bought a couple of years ago. All of the differences (except for the mesh, which I’m still not sure about) were major improvements, so now the women’s replicas look exactly like the men’s replicas do. Therefore, I think the Reebok Women’s NFL Replica Jersey is an exceptional product, and well worth the $59.99 price tag. This is a must-have for all you female football fans out there!!